Daniel E. Holifield said nothing Friday afternoon after leaving the federal courthouse downtown, where he pleaded not guilty to new criminal charges.
Details contained in a pair of new indictments paint the picture of a man who used his position as fleet supervisor at the Mobile County Sheriff’s Office to steal hundreds of thousands of dollars through a variety of methods from January 2021 to May 2023.
A federal indictment handed up this week alleges fraud totaling more than $310,000, while the new state charges involve more than $80,000. That comes on top of a state court indictment that the 52-year-old Mobile man already faced alleging that he stole vehicles from the department’s impound lot.
“There’s no doubt in my mind that if this is proven to a jury that this is reprehensible conduct,” Mobile County District Attorney Keith Blackwood said at a news conference Friday. “This is taxpayer dollars; this is private company dollars; and he is alleged to have stolen this over a period of time.”
U.S. Magistrate Judge Sonja Bivins allowed Holifield to remain free pending trial. She set the trial for the August term.
A lawyer from the Federal Defender’s Office declined to comment after Friday’s arraignment. Holifield’s attorney in the state case, Dennis Knizley, told FOX10 News that he has been in contact with federal investigators for a little more than a month.
“We’re not in a position to address these charges or reach any resolution with the state or federal authorities at this time,” he said.
14 federal criminal counts
The federal indictment charges Holifield with 10 counts of bank fraud, one count of money laundering and three counts of tax evasion.
Large sums of overtime – roughly 50 hours a week in 2022 – significantly boosted Holifield’s base income of a little more than $80,000. Records show his annual income was $279,947 in 2021, $217,904 in 2022 and $179,729 in 2023. That made him the department’s highest-paid employee.
The federal indictment alleges that Holifield failed to report significant additional income on his tax returns – earnings that prosecutors allege came from fraud.
Holifield stands accused of obtaining duplicate payments to companies doing business with the Sheriff’s Office. Prosecutors allege that he would submit one invoice to the Sheriff’s Office and another to the Mobile County Commission, using one check to pay the vendor and pocketing the other. The indictment cites about 80 transactions involving 11 different companies totaling $236,332 in deposits.
The indictment also alleges that Holifield deposited about 18 insurance checks that were intended to pay claims on property owned either by the Sheriff’s Office or the Mobile County Commission. Those deposits totaled about $74,356.
Theft by deception alleged
The new state court indictment charges Holifield with three counts of theft by deception, alleging that he defrauded the Sheriff’s Office, University of South Alabama Police Department and a private security company to the tune of more than $80,000. Blackwood accused Holifield of submitting identical overtime claims to different supervisors.
“There are some cases where he was claiming to be on duty while provably being off duty at a casino in Mississippi, and then there are cases where he billed multiple companies for work that was at the same time,” Blackwood said.
Holifield already faced charges from an indictment last year alleging that he used Mobile County Sheriff’s Office letterhead to buy 10 cars from 2020 to 2023.
Prosecutors also allege that Holifield stole a 2005 Pontiac in 2020 and a 2013 Highlander, as well as a 2015 Malibu in 2021 from the department’s impound lot.
Holifield joined the Sheriff’s Office in 1998 and rose to the rank of sergeant. Mobile County Sheriff Paul Burch said Holifield retired in April 2023 with a pending disciplinary proceeding. The sheriff said he uncovered the improprieties within a couple of months after taking office in 2023 after a vendor called to complain about not receiving a payment.
“We immediately put a number of checks and balances in place,” Burch said. “No one person can make purchases, can, you know, do the vendor purchases there. There are number of checks and balances before a check is cut for that, or equipment is purchased. There’s at least, probably, three hands that touch that and a system that goes through, so nothing like that can ever happen again.”
Burch said he takes ethical lapses by his employees extremely seriously.
“Any person entrusted with, you know, the public, being a public servant, should be held accountable, just like anyone else, if not more so,” he said. “Because he’s violated his oath of office and the trust that the public puts in law enforcement.”
Records show the Sheriff’s Office paid a large amount of overtime to other employees at the same time that Holifield is accused of committing fraud. But Burch said a review did not turn up evidence of wrongdoing by anyone else. He said his department has cooperated fully with prosecutors.
“We turned over our initial report and findings but continued to work with them through the past couple of years to make sure they had everything they needed for a successful prosecution in this case,” he said.