The anti-fraud voice to America’s courts
The Coalition files amicus curiae (“friend of the court”) briefs as a voice to federal and state courts on key anti-fraud issue. These decisions set national precedents. Important decisions greatly strengthen or damage how we combat fraud. Outcomes directly affect consumers and insurers alike.
Over more than 20 years the Coalition remains a highly credible voice to courts. Coalition amicus briefs carry great weight and impact decisions.
Our incisive briefs reflect our national leadership reputation — and the diverse voices of our members. Judges cite our arguments in landmark decisions supporting a stronger fraud fight. Courts listen when our nation’s anti-fraud leaders speak.
Cases are reviewed by our Amicus Committee using these standards:
- Issues: Are the facts and pleadings properly framed to address substantive anti-fraud issues? Both civil and criminal cases are appropriate for amicus brief filings.
- Implications: Does the case have national implications? Greater weight is given to cases where the decision will impact fraud laws nationally or in multiple states.
- Applicability: Does the issue further the Coalition’s mission by advancing the interests of all constituents?
- Timing: Sufficient research and drafting time are necessary to adequately prepare briefs for filing.
- Jurisdiction: What is the size of the jurisdiction and its potential impact on the anti-fraud fight.
- Judicial level: Normally filings are limited to state or federal courts of appeal or supreme courts.
Coalition amicus briefs
Keystone RX LLC vs. Bureau of Workers' Compensation Fee Review Hearing Office (Pennsylvania Supreme Court, 2020)
• Issue: Right of providers to participate in review hearings/compound pharmaceutical fraud.
Illinois v. Family Vision Care (Illinois Supreme Court, 2020)
• Issue: State financial loss on citizen whistleblower actions.
Dr. Robert D. Haar, M.D. v. Nationwide Mutual (New York Court of Appeals, 2019)
• Issue: Immunity for good faith fraud reporting.
Keodalah vs. Allstate Insurance Company (Supreme Court of Washington State, 2019)
• Issue: Personal liability in bad faith lawsuits.
Restoration 1 of Port St. Lucie v. Ark Royal Insurance (Florida Supreme Court, 2019)
• Issue: Assignment of benefits rights.
Andrew Carothers, MD, PC v. Progressive Insurance (New York Court of Appeals, 2019)
• Issue: Sham medical clinics.
Allstate v. Rehab Alliance of Texas (Supreme Court of Texas, 2016)
• Issue: Standards for pursuing recovery actions.
State Farm Mutual Automobile v. Roniesha Adams (Supreme Court of Kentucky, 2016)
• Issue: Examinations Under Oath.
Jocelyn Zolna Pitts. v. ATI Holdings (Appellate Court of Illinois, First Judicial District, 2014)
• Issue: Application of state whistleblower fraud law.
Hambarian vs. Orange County Superior Court (California Supreme Court, 2001)
Issue: victim participation in prosecution of insurance fraud
Commonwealth of Massachusetts v. James N. Ellis, Sr. (Massachusetts Supreme Court, 1998)
• Issue: insurer funding of state fraud bureaus.